SCA marking scheme: how the MRCGP SCA is marked
How each of the twelve SCA cases is marked, what the three domains and four grades mean, how the RCGP sets the pass mark, and what your feedback tells you.
How SCA marking works
The SCA has twelve simulated consultations, each lasting twelve minutes, with 3 minutes’ reading time before each case. The whole exam is recorded, and examiners watch and mark the recordings after the exam day. Each of your twelve cases is marked by a different examiner, and an examiner keeps to the same case throughout the exam. The RCGP says its examiners are trained to mark in the same way and are calibrated before each exam. They apply standard grade descriptors to a marking schedule written for that case. Trained role-players play the patients. A case looks the same for every candidate, but it responds to how you consult, and the RCGP says there is no preferred consultation model and no script to follow. Physical examination is not assessed in the SCA.
The three marking domains
Every case is marked in the same three domains. This is how the RCGP describes them, with examples drawn from its feedback statements. The RCGP is clear that these capabilities are not a tick box: you are not expected to show every one of them in every case.
- Data gathering and diagnosis: Gathering and organising relevant, targeted information to address the patient’s needs, with a structured, informed approach to problem-solving. The feedback statements for this domain include using the information already available in the case, picking up psychological and social factors, and generating and testing differential diagnoses.
- Clinical management and medical complexity: Forming safe and appropriate management options, with a commitment to the best care in the short and long term. Its feedback statements cover referral, prescribing, investigations, prevention and health promotion, managing risk and co-morbidity, handling uncertainty, follow-up and safety-netting, and time management in the consultation.
- Relating to others: Ethical awareness and the ability to communicate in a person-centred way. Its feedback statements cover listening and responding to cues, exploring the person’s agenda, health beliefs and preferences, adapting explanations, showing respect without judgement, owning decisions, teamwork and recognising safeguarding concerns.
The four grades
In each case, the examiner grades each of the three domains. All four grades are measured against one standard: a newly qualified, independent GP. The RCGP’s published guidance does not give a number of marks for each grade.
- Clear pass: the domain is shown above that standard.
- Pass: the domain is shown sufficiently, at that standard.
- Fail: the domain is not shown sufficiently for that standard.
- Clear fail: the domain is shown clearly below that standard.
How the overall result and pass mark work
Your result depends on how you perform across the whole exam. Your marks from all twelve cases are combined to give your overall mark, and you do not have to pass a set number of cases. Falling short of the pass mark in one case does not, on its own, mean you have failed the exam. There is no fixed pass mark for each case. As well as grading the domains, examiners judge your general performance in each case. The RCGP uses those judgements in a standard-setting method called Borderline Regression to set the pass mark for every case. Clinical management and medical complexity carries more weight than the other two domains. The RCGP does not publish the exact weighting. After each sitting, the RCGP publishes a summary report on its marking and results page.
Results and feedback
Results are published at 17:00 on the results date for your sitting. Every candidate receives feedback with their results, not only those who fail. Feedback is specific to each case and linked to the three domains. Any domain an examiner fails receives a feedback statement, and candidates who pass a domain may receive statements too. The statements play no part in the marking: they describe what fell short, such as data gathering that was not enough for a safe assessment, or follow-up and safety-netting arrangements that were missing. The RCGP publishes an educational note for each feedback statement. It suggests going through your feedback with your trainer, and giving most weight to statements that repeat across several cases rather than to a single one.
Is there a CSA marking sheet for the SCA?
Many people still search for a CSA marking sheet. The CSA was replaced by the Recorded Consultation Assessment (RCA), and the RCGP describes the SCA as the permanent replacement for the RCA. The SCA has no single marking sheet to tick off. Each case has its own marking schedule, and examiners apply the same grade descriptors to it. What the RCGP does publish is the closest thing to a marking sheet you can practise with: the three domains and the capabilities under each, the four grade descriptors, and the feedback statements with their educational notes.
Using the marking scheme in your practice
Because your overall mark comes from all twelve cases, steady performance in every case matters. Time management appears among the Clinical management feedback statements, so practise reaching a shared plan, with follow-up and safety-netting, inside the 12 minutes. After each practice case, note what went well and what to change under each of the three domains, and use the wording of the RCGP feedback statements to name any gap. Look for the same gap across several cases before you change your approach. Rehearse with exam timings, and check your consultation structure against a template so the plan is never squeezed out at the end.
SCA marking questions
- What is the SCA pass mark? There is no single fixed figure. The RCGP sets a pass mark for each case using Borderline Regression, based on examiners’ judgements of general performance in that case. Your overall result comes from your combined mark across all twelve cases.
- Do I need to pass a certain number of cases? No. The RCGP says you do not have to pass a set number of cases, and one weak case does not, by itself, mean you fail.
- Who marks my SCA? A different examiner marks each of your twelve cases from the recording, after the exam day. Each examiner keeps to the same case throughout the exam, using a marking schedule written for that case.
- Does everyone get feedback? Yes. The RCGP gives feedback to every candidate with their results. A failed domain always receives a feedback statement, and passing candidates may receive statements too.
- Is physical examination marked in the SCA? No. The RCGP says physical examination is not assessed in the SCA. It is covered in workplace-based assessment (WPBA) instead.
- When should I re-sit after a fail? The RCGP suggests agreeing the timing with your trainer, who may advise more consultation practice before another attempt. You book a re-sit the same way you booked your first attempt.
Try a practice case
The free practice case page explains the five-minute Avatar taster that eligible free accounts can try, and what it includes.
RCGP sources
Based on the RCGP’s published SCA guidance, checked on 16 November 2026. The RCGP can update its guidance, so read its marking and results page before you sit. Independent educational resource. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the NHS or the RCGP.
Please enable JavaScript for the full interactive MRCGP SCA practice platform.