The behaviours that quietly decide the mark
Very few candidates fail the SCA because they did not know the medicine. They fail because a concern was never elicited, an explanation was delivered in jargon, a plan was announced rather than agreed, or a safety-net was so vague the patient could not have acted on it. These are learnable behaviours, and they are examinable in every case.
A structure that fits inside twelve minutes
Consultation models — Calgary–Cambridge, Neighbour, Pendleton and the rest — are not there to be recited. They exist because an unstructured consultation reliably runs out of time before it reaches the part that carries most of the marks: the shared plan and the safety-net. Choose one model, internalise it until it is invisible, and let it protect the ending of your consultation. The model is scaffolding; the marks come from what it lets you finish.
- A consultation structure practised until it no longer requires conscious thought
- Eliciting ideas, concerns and expectations as conversation, not as an interrogation
- Explaining in plain language, then checking what the patient actually took away
- Safety-netting that names the symptom, the action, and the timeframe
What separates a good consultation from a safe-looking one
These are the behaviours candidates most often believe they performed, and most often did not. Record yourself once and check honestly.
- You asked about concerns — but did you respond to the answer, or note it and move on?
- You explained the diagnosis — but would the patient repeat it in their own words?
- You agreed a plan — or did you present one and pause briefly for objection?
- You safety-netted — but did you say which symptom, to whom, and within what timeframe?
- You finished on time — or did you finish because the time finished you?
Consultation behaviours by clinical context
Some contexts expose particular behaviours: paediatrics tests safety-netting, mental health tests risk within rapport.
Please enable JavaScript for the full interactive MRCGP SCA practice platform.